Need some opinions.....Because my judgement sucks
 

Don't worry guys he is retracting his offer.

Back

The others.

To start with obviously I'd be wary about what the screwdown might have done to the 54 Aaron...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm more concerned the the 1954 aaron looks fake. But yeah the pic are hard to tell but looks like a counterfeit.

Take them out of the cruddy holders and reshoot.

If it is real what do you think it graded? What about the other cards?

'54 Aaron probably a 2 with that upper right issue.

Aaron
 

Holders awful

The 58 Aaron/Mantle looks suspect too. I wouldn't touch the 54.

Cheers,
Patrick

Better pictures. Give me opinions.

Also pulled this after maginifying on my phone. Is this the correct print?

Trust these other guys more than me, but I would have guessed all were real. Getting harder and harder to tell these days. Sure miss when all reprints said as much on the back.

They all have the correct print matrix so I believe they are real. Unfortunately it looks like he is retracting his offer.