Purchased Auto collection. Looking for feedback. What is good, what isn't. Thanks
 

Here is a link to pics:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/171175.../shares/g4qKA6

Here is a list. Please let me know if you know for sure something is bad or something is good. Obviously the PSA, Steiner and Upper Deck stuff is good.

Thanks

* 2004 Yankees Base $3000
* Dwight Gooden Hat $60
* Bo Jackson Hat $70
* 2003 Yankees Helmet $1000
* Doc Gooden “no hitter” 8x10 $60 19x16
* Tino Martinez Photo $100 19x16
* Aaron Boone ALCS Walk off $60 19x16
* Roger Clemens Yankees Hat off $100
* Don Zimmer $60 19x16
* Bucky Dent/Mike Torrez 8x10 $100
* Yankees Team 2003 All Star Game photo $300
* Derek Jeter 8x10 sliding $400
* John Wettland $100
* Alex Rodriguez Sports Illustrated $100
* Hideki Matsui 2003 World Series $150
* Joe Montana Notre Dame Photo $200
* Joe Montana 2000 Hall of Fame Photo /5000 $300
* Jeter/Giambi/Posada 8x10 Photo $150
* 2003 Yankees Team 8x10 Photo $300
* 1999 Yankees World Series Photo $300
* Clemens/Piazza Photo $200
* 1999 Yankees World Series 8x10 Photo Game 4 $300
* George Brett Pine Tar Incident $250
* Mattingly/Brett/Boggs Photo $150 19x16
* Yankees 2001 ALCS Photo $300 19x16
* Mickey Mantle/Whitey Ford/Billy Martin $500 19x16
* Mickey Mantle Photo $500 19x16
* Paul O’Neil “911 Yankee Logo” Photo $150
* Joe DiMaggio Photo $400 19x27
* Ted Williams Photo $600 19x27
* Don Mattingly “Hit Man” Photo $200
* Kevin Garnett Gold Collection #d 10/21 $1000 32x32 or smaller
* Yankees Team Jersey 2002 $800 32x32
* Alex Rodriguez Jersey $300 32x32
* Joe Montana Notre Dame Jersey $300 32x32
* Derek Jeter Rookie Stats 2001 Jersey $1500 32x32
* Kevin Garnett Jersey $350 36x36 SOLD
* Tanaka Jersey (FRAME NOT INCLUDED) $350
* Paul O’Neill Jersey $100 36x36
* Derek Jeter Bat $600
* Yankees Team Ball $600
* Yankees Team Ball $600
* Moncada Ball $50
* Aaron Judge Ball $400
* Derek Jeter Ball $500
* Mariano Rivera Ball $500
* Mike Trout Ball 09 25th PK $500
* Paul O’neill 1996 World Series Ball $100
* Brian Cashman Ball $30
* Barry Bonds Ball $200
* Miguel Cabrera Ball $200
* Bryce Harper Ball Luke 1:37 $300
* Alex Rodriguez Ball $200
* Albert Pujols Ball $300
* Brian McCann Ball $50
* Yasiel Puig Ball $100

This is from Brian's B/S/T thread below.


http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=268418

Saw on your other thread that you weren't ready to agree 100% with Chris on his opinions.

Just an FYI, if Chris says it is bad, it is bad. He doesn't opine in the negative unless he is sure from what I've seen.

Mike

Okay sounds good. Wish he would tell me something is good, even if its the PSA stuff.

why when you wrote "obviously the psa, steiner, ud stuff is good"?

I just want some positive feedback on something.

I marked the stuff he said was bad

* 2004 Yankees Base $3000 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Dwight Gooden Hat $60
* Bo Jackson Hat $70
* 2003 Yankees Helmet $1000
* Doc Gooden “no hitter” 8x10 $60 19x16
* Tino Martinez Photo $100 19x16
* Aaron Boone ALCS Walk off $60 19x16
* Roger Clemens Yankees Hat off $100
* Don Zimmer $60 19x16
* Bucky Dent/Mike Torrez 8x10 $100
* Yankees Team 2003 All Star Game photo $300 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Derek Jeter 8x10 sliding $400 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* John Wettland $100
* Alex Rodriguez Sports Illustrated $100
* Hideki Matsui 2003 World Series $150
* Joe Montana Notre Dame Photo $200
* Joe Montana 2000 Hall of Fame Photo /5000 $300
* Jeter/Giambi/Posada 8x10 Photo $150 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* 2003 Yankees Team 8x10 Photo $300 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* 1999 Yankees World Series Photo $300 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Clemens/Piazza Photo $200
* 1999 Yankees World Series 8x10 Photo Game 4 $300 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* George Brett Pine Tar Incident $250
* Mattingly/Brett/Boggs Photo $150 19x16
* Yankees 2001 ALCS Photo $300 19x16 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Mickey Mantle/Whitey Ford/Billy Martin $500 19x16 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Mickey Mantle Photo $500 19x16 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Paul O’Neil “911 Yankee Logo” Photo $150
* Joe DiMaggio Photo $400 19x27
* Ted Williams Photo $600 19x27
* Don Mattingly “Hit Man” Photo $200
* Kevin Garnett Gold Collection #d 10/21 $1000 32x32 or smaller
* Yankees Team Jersey 2002 $800 32x32
* Alex Rodriguez Jersey $300 32x32
* Joe Montana Notre Dame Jersey $300 32x32
* Derek Jeter Rookie Stats 2001 Jersey $1500 32x32
* Kevin Garnett Jersey $350 36x36 SOLD
* Tanaka Jersey (FRAME NOT INCLUDED) $350
* Paul O’Neill Jersey $100 36x36
* Derek Jeter Bat $600 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Yankees Team Ball $600 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Yankees Team Ball $600 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Moncada Ball $50
* Aaron Judge Ball $400
* Derek Jeter Ball $500 NOT AVAILABLE. QUESTIONABLE AUTHENTICITY BY BOARD MEMBER
* Mariano Rivera Ball $500
* Mike Trout Ball 09 25th PK $500
* Paul O’neill 1996 World Series Ball $100
* Brian Cashman Ball $30
* Barry Bonds Ball $200
* Miguel Cabrera Ball $200
* Bryce Harper Ball Luke 1:37 $300
* Alex Rodriguez Ball $200
* Albert Pujols Ball $300
* Brian McCann Ball $50
* Yasiel Puig Ball $100

But why post here, initially with no caveat, when you were already told on BST that many items were bad?

Because all the items are not bad.

Jim Stinson taught me something a long time ago...

"If you take a cup of water and add one drop of urine, you now have a cup of urine"

Take that for what it's worth...There are way too many new members here to subject them to a forgery on our BST. BST at Net54 has always been a place you could come and feel comfortable with a purchase...Think that through the next time you post without knowing 100% that you are selling authentic items.

Anything from a company or store with a home made COA is probably best assumed to be forgeries.

I respect your comment and agree that I should have done more research before offering all for sale. That being said, I took them down pretty quickly, for whatever that is worth.

Best assumed yes, but I am sure plenty of good items exist with "home made" COAs.

Not unless it comes from a hobby source with a reputation. If you're a professional dealer then you are more than familiar with PSA / JSA and the like. There would be no monetary advantage to not having your items certed other than they're not going to pass.

Home made coas have no attachment to the piece, itself. PSA and JSA put a sticker on the piece. You have the Tino picture with Joes cert. I would trust anything that I bought from Joe. But it’s impossible to know if that’s the one he sold or if someone switched the cert to another picture.

I wonder if that is a Jim original or did he read it somewhere?
It is a beauty, whatever it is :).

Brian, can we see some of the stuff you did not post. I would love to see all your Jeters

I think all the jeters are in the pics thanks