Jackie Robinson Autograph - FOR THE LOVE OF GOD HELP ME!!!! Fake or Real. Want Refund
 

Hello everyone,

My question to you guys is to explain in detail of how this Jackie Robinson is FAKE. I am very certain it is fake after doing research. Unfortunately, I did this research after I bought it... Yes I know I was an idiot for buying it. Lastly, no it did not have a COA...

I am posting this, because I want my hard earned money back. I need someone to help me explain its inauthenticity, so I can justify returning this to the seller tomorrow. I am not going to spend $150 to get it denied by PSA... Also, I would like to print out your responses to show its not just me that believes this is a FAKE Jackie Robinson, but the opinion of many.

I purchased the Jackie Robinson autographed magazine last year out of IGNORANCE, TRUST, AND IMPULSE. Another fun fact, I found out it is not even Jackie depicted in the "run-down" on the cover. The man I bought this had multiple stories of ballplayers he met throughout his lifetime. He didn't care to send things into PSA or JSA, because it was expensive. Which usually I would just walk away, but his stories were so elaborate and believable that I stayed. I don't normally trust people, but the stories he told me about we're amazing. I love baseball and just listened with utter enjoyment. He is an autograph dealer from Topeka, Kansas. I bought this at a local card show in Oklahoma City. He said he obtained this piece off a dealer (apparently a wealthy accountant from Arizona).

Now please everyone who has knowledge on Jackie Robinson signatures can you please post everything you know about how this is not real.
I mean maybe I am wrong and it is real... Just someone can you please help!

Thank you all,

Colby

More pics
 

Pics :confused:

definitely fake

1949 signed ball
 

Here is my authentic ball signed by the Brooklyn Dodgers in '49. match the letters they are very inconsistent with your sig. I would ask for refund.

I believe it is fake. The J, K, R, and N all look like they were written slowly and are not free flowing like most other signatures I have seen.

Its terrible. letter formation is bad, especially the "R" and even the "J". And yes, no flow at all, drawn out.

Did the seller offer a guarantee? if it was sold "as is" you may be stuck with ti. NEVER buy a good autograph like Jackie's w/out researching or maybe posting it here, or PM'g one of the real experts on here, and giving them a fee for their help.

A hard lesson to learn for sure, hope u don't get stuck, but sadly, you might.

Here's mine:

I think it's real

Colby,

Sell it to Doug.

Looks slowly drawn with some definite jitter to some of the letters. Most Jackie's you see, including mine, have a quickness about them with no jitters.
I wouldn't touch this one if it were me.

X2...classic.

That's a good one.

this is my jackie pencil auto. from an autograph leather book with gil hodges, and 30 other autos.

My refund
 

The guy was an asshole about the whole thing but I managed to get a couple ex-nrmt mantles (1960&1961)... All in all I'm just happy it is over with

Not bad. Just need to tread so lightly, especially with high dollar stuff like Jackie.