What to buy?
 

In my senility, I want to buy a really good card to be the foundation of my collection. Price range 3-5 thousand possibly.
I was thinking a 55 Koufax or 53 Mantle Topps, or 52 Mantle Bowman.
Were it you, what's your menu ?
Thanks.

1959 Topps
 

,for your price range , look at '59 Gibson . ??

..

I really think it depends on the condition you're going for. In lower condition, you can easily buy two/three of those cards. You can get a Koufax in a PSA 3 for the 8-900 range, and use the remainder of those funds to Purchase either a 53 or 52 Mantle.

I suggest a 54 Topps Aaron. It’s been on the rise for a while now. Especially signed rookies.

Mantle is still the answer to almost any question about best postwar cards. If not Mantle, agree with the Aaron rookie. I wouldn't get a pitcher.

Best 53 Mantle
 

The 53 Mantle is I think a good choice. Find one that is dead-centered and the best you can afford.

Get two cards 1962 -Gibson and Mc Covey
Super tough cards!
57 Brooks Robinson comes to mind

53 Mantle would be my vote, one of my favorite cards.

1953 Topps Robinson or Paige

T206 Walter Johnson, hands at chest, PSA 5
T206 Mathewson, white cap, PSA 5

Out of those 3 you listed, I would go with the 52 bowman Mantle, and you should be able land a 52 bowman Mays with your price range. That would be a great foundation.

Not on your list but I'd buy the best Topps Jackie Robinson I could find in your price range.

For the bedrock of your collection, you have to go with the '53 Mantle. The best of the card manufacturers and the most beloved ballplayer of the last 70 years.

I vote for the 54 Aaron as well. Seems undervalued relative to his contribution to the game.