Prices fetch for the Mantle 311's @ Huggins&Scott
 

Ok. Huggins and Scott had 3 'A' variation Mantle #311 Rcs for sale:
Which one looked best and which was a steal...and which you rather had?

A. SOLD for 4750.00
http://www.hugginsandscott.com/pl/69...pps_mantle.jpg

B. SOLD for 2750.00
http://www.hugginsandscott.com/pl/69..._mantle_mc.jpg

C: SOLD for 3250.00
http://www.hugginsandscott.com/pl/69...mantle_sgc.jpg

Not sure I would label any of them a "steal", but the first one is by far the best.

The first one is the winner in my opinion. If centering is most important to someone then you could make a case for #3.

For the price I'd take number two all day. A 52 Mantle for under $3k? Yes please.

The choice would be between the PSA 1 and SGC 1 (the 1 MC is way too OC for me). While I'd usually go for the card with better centering (the SGC example), the PSA 1 has a much better front surface and better overall eye appeal. I'd pick the PSA 1.

If I had any interest in that card I would buy the first PSA 1 card everytime because of the better colors. Then the middle card, off center cards do not bother me at all. Lastly the SCG card, just hate cards that scuffed up.

#1 w/o question IMO