Best Baseball Player Born on Thanksgiving top 3
 

for this year... past or present players..

Top 2 are easy...Left Gomez..and Hugh Duffy.....

Number 3 is Matt Carpenter imo..over Harold Reynolds

if Thanksgiving was on the 27th..

Its Ivan Rodriguez, Jimmy Rollins than Bullet Joe Bush

This is very specific criteria. Being a Cardinals fan and thus Matt Carpenter fan I still have to state he would not be my number 3, but he only has 5 years so it could change.

I would choose 3. Bob Johnson 4. Chuck Finley T5. Matt Carpenter/Bob Elliott