T206 / T205 You Grade 'em - For Fun!
 

Hey, it's Friday! For fun, take a look at these three important cards and guess the PSA grade. I recently sent these in, I'll respond back with the final grade as soon as they've been assigned....GOOD LUCK!


Tom Overstreet

50, A, 50

Good luck!

grades
 

4, 4, 3.5
I hope you get better grades than my estimates! BTW~~~GREAT CARDS!
Have a wonderful weekend,
Bill Hedin

So, that would be a PSA 4, 'A', and 4, right? Thanks...keep 'em coming!

FYI, the Cobb isn't trimmed, just placed lower on the scanner...

Thanks Bill, you too! NCAA early rounds ;)

40, 40, and 30

I'm going...
 

3
, a, 2

I recognize them, so you were the winner of the A-1 Auction in Maitland....

Heh.

My guess: 4, 5, 4

pretty cards!

4.5, 5 (if not trimmed), 3.5

4, 4, 3...

Yes, I did win the larger lot, good eye! There was a smaller lot with a T205 Young and Cobb that I was an underbidder on. There was also an early 60's Yankees team-signed (no Mantle) ball that I didn't get, wish I would've been a bit more agressive on that one!

5, 5, 4

4,4.5,3.5

4,5 and 3

4, 4, 3

4.5, 5, 4... Good luck!

Psa 4,4 3

Alright, it looks like everyone so far is in 'close' agreement...I should have the grades by Monday....stay tuned!

No 2's or anything higher than a 5...keep 'em coming!!!

Thank you all for your input.

50/4, a, 50/4.

grades
 

4, 5, 3

grades
 

Sgc 60 50 40 hidden creases?......

4.5,4.5.3.5

4.5, 5, 3
JimB

I'll second that. Agree with Jim.

No hidden creases that I could see with out magnification.

I think I would be happy with those grades! See soon :eek:

The results are in!
 

Okay, so no one guessed exacly right, but three had the last two correct...

T206 Walter Johnson '5'
T206 Cobb - Green Background '4'
T205 Mathewson - '3'

That was good fun.....thanks!

I will post pics of the graded cards if anyone is interested.

Marty got it right
 

I was one in at 4, 4, 3.

But I would consider Marty's 60, 50, 40 guess to be spot on.

Credit where credit is due, even if the Johnson was overgraded:D.

Spot on!
 

Yup, you're right Frank, thanks for catching that :o

Great job, Marty!!!

Overgraded, undergraded...its all in the law of averages.

Did sgc grade these? ;)

They're all PSA graded.

Psa
 

Congrats on the 5 on Johnson and especially the PSA 4 on the Cobb. Those are great cards! Like some others I was worried that you might get the dreaded "Auth" for the wavy top border on that Cobb.

Hey, thanks Ron! Yeah, you never really know what the graders are going to see....and what they don't...:confused:

I'm happy with the grades, and, more importantly with the cards themselves.