Giles/Harridge opinion
 

What do you guys think on both of these. TPA's at times have given totally contradictory opinions one time saying Harridge good, Giles bad, other times saying the opposite. I like the one on the left and think one on the right could be OK with a late in life Harridge but would prefer your opinion. I actually have a slabbed one too that I think is no good, tho not sure. Thanks
Attachment 321164

Attachment 321165

My opinion, for what it's worth, is that the first one I think the Harridge is good and Giles I don't like. The second one I like the Giles, and the Harridge is really slow (but could be because of age) but I'd pass on that one unless I had it in hand to look at. The last one in the slab I like the Giles and cannot tell the Harridge.