What woul be a fair price for a Christy Mathewson T206 White Cap in PSA 2.5?
 

I meant would with a d.....?

You should look into vintagecardprices.com. Also search eBay completed auctions for recent sales and you can get a good idea of market value for commonly sold cards like this.

Best regards.

AndyH

$26

???????

Re: What woul be a fair price for a Christy Mathewson T206 White Cap in PSA 2.5?
 

You'll have to forgive Jeff. He's just exagerating to drive up the value of the one in his collection.:)

The research I have done shows 375$ is a decent and the average price paid.

I bought a 2 sometime ago for about $300.

I will keep looking then for a better price thanks.

I figured Jeff had something up his sleeve...but not for $26! ;)

As far as the original question goes, it's hard to judge a card on grade alone. If that 2.5 was graded that way only because of a minor flaw and it looks more like a 5, then it should go for more than the average sales. If you're looking for the avg sales of a normal looking 2.5 matty, then that's a different story. Check eBay completed listings and cardtarget.com to help you out a bit.