Is this even possible?
|
Quote:
|
If you read the listing, it is not Heritage auction, it is American Heritage. The card is in remarkably nice condition for one that has been around so long. I personally believe it is undoubtedly fake, and I checked on PSA's site, and they too list the card as "IMP".
|
My bad, read the listing with my eyes, but my mind ready different words :)
|
These Artvue Type 1 HOF postcards were produced from 53-55:eek:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Tinker could have signed HOF related items, BUT could not have signed this item because it was produced after his death? I really don't know much about the HOF postcards so it is good to know when they are produced. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Artvue postcards
The quickest way to tell on the black and white HOF postcards is the bolt holes on the plaques are empty on 1953-55. On 56 up they covered the holes.
|
Quote:
|
You are right, I did not look that far down and see the back. The card is possible I assume.
|
Quote:
Source: http://www.ebay.com/gds/Albertype-B-...1026384/g.html |
The same seller has this Grover Cleveland Alexander, which looks too good to be true. I don't know enough about his signature nor Tinker's, but I do know that B&W Plaques are highly forged and most of the real ones I've seen don't look as though they were kept in a vault for years. I'd be leary.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/GROVER-ALEXA...item4acd5f1b1b |
The Alex is terrible.
|
Quote:
|
So.... If it is "possible" he signed it, would anyone have an opinion as to the authenticity of the signature. I personally have not, and would not, bid either way but am still curious.
|
I did not like the Tinker at all when I saw it. I then saw the seller's Alexander, which is a clear fake, sealing the deal for me. Don't touch either of them.
|
Both of them are fugly and not worth any bid.
|
Tinker sold for around $350, Alex for around $220.
A fraction of what they would have sold for if legit. |
Richard whos buying these things:confused:
|
Quote:
The Florida garbage (Mantle, Williams, DiMaggio, etc.) forgeries are being scooped up for resale in little auctions that are out of the limelight or they are going to CC. B&W plaks do not sell the way those photos do so it is hard to say where they are going. The serious collector who is buying B&W plaks is probably smart enough to avoid this ebay crap. But I would love to know who is buying this stuff. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:28 PM. |