Eye appeal vs technical grade
We had a thread awhile back with regard to eye appeal versus technical grade, with what I recall was a general consensus that the former may often trump the latter insofar as value is concerned. I bought the 1910 Sepia PC796 Walter Johnson in the 2011 REA auction for a relatively hefty price, despite the fact that it was accurately described as having a microscopic pinhole, as well as very slight indentations at two corners from having been very well preserved in a photo-type album. While the card was graded "good" by SGC, it truly has a nearmint appearance, with four great corners and is well-centered. The bottom line is buy what appears pleasing to you in the best grade you can find or afford. If the card appears displeasing to you, chances are it will not appeal to others either, in the event you later decide to part with it.
Happy collecting,
Larry
|