Quote:
Originally Posted by packs
Piazza didn't get in because he has always been surrounded with PED speculation. Frank Thomas has never been associated with PEDs and he continues to be one of the criminally overlooked players of all time. The guy was a monster. Back to back MVPs with 3 additional top 3 finishes. He hit 40 homers 5 times, drove in 100 runs 8 years in a row and 11 times in his career.
Absolutely a HOFer.
|
Not one shred of evidence against either. Speculation can easily be started about most players from their era...how do you draw that imaginary line?
Positionally, Piazza is so much better than Frank Thomas. Piazza is arguably the greatest hitting catcher of all time.