I would tend to say no because I feel there would be no winners. For example. what era do you want the Mantle, Ruth , and Gehrig from? As we all know their signatures, especially Mantle's , varied greatly during their lives. What happens to the signature your grandfather gave you of Mantle that he received from his second cousin's secretary who got it from some guy who supposedly washed Mantle's car that you have proudly displayed and framed and we all diss it?
Also how do TPAs enter into this?
How do we deal with a more obscure signature, such as ,for example Josh Gibson?
Lastly would we also be screening autographs that are in auctions to help decide to bid or not?
I agree with the above posts and would say not a good idea, but I respect the spirit with which you proposed the thread.
|