Quote:
Originally Posted by irv
Very interesting, and disturbing thread! 
I haven't sent any of my cards in for grading, but this one pretty much seals the deal for me. SGC it is. |
Sadly, I'm sure SGC isn't void of mistakes either. SGC graded a high $ Mantle of mine that PSA said was recolored...not by me. Of course PSA could have been wrong on that one, but I don't know. And BGS went out of favor for me a long time ago when I found out they grade sheet cut cards with no hand cut qualifier (I learned the hard way).
For me, I will continue to use PSA because I think for the most part they have been consistent with their grading. In fact, I am about to send out another 40+ card submission.
I think PSA just went a little too far with customer satisfaction. They knew I bought the 8 and they wanted me to keep the 8 even though they did spill their "pumpkin spice latte" on the card
I would have rather just gotten a PSA 3 back from them and been compensated for the difference.