View Single Post
  #24  
Old 04-25-2019, 09:02 PM
nolemmings's Avatar
nolemmings nolemmings is offline
Todd Schultz
Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 3,766
Default

Zach, here is my response to your recent posts:

"Cards on my list with a "?" as to what type (on your list as Type 1's):
Eddie Collins – I have confirmed this also
Jacques Fournier– I have confirmed this also

-Cards on my list as Type 1's but not on your list:
Dave Davenport
Bill Donovan (pitching)
Walter Schang
Charles Stengel--I have confirmed this also
Milton Stock--I have confirmed this also

-Card I have listed as Type 2 only (also listed on your list as Type 1):
J. Carlisle Smith --I have confirmed this for only Type 1 also

Type 2 differences:

-Cards I have listed only as Type 1's (Type 2's on your list):
Grover Alexander--I have confirmed this also for both
J. Franklin Baker--I have confirmed this also for both
Dave Bancroft--I have confirmed this also for both
Geo. J. Burns--I have confirmed this also for both
Owen Bush--I have confirmed this also for both
Max Carey-–I have confirmed this for Type 2
Harry Covaleskie-- I have confirmed this for Type 2
Dave Davenport-- I have confirmed this for Type 2 (from Rhett)
Bill Donovan-- I have confirmed this for Type 2
Urban Faber
John Henry--I have confirmed this also for both
Harry Hooper--I have confirmed this also for both
Rogers Hornsby--I have confirmed this also for both
James Johnston--I have confirmed this also for both
John McGraw--I have confirmed this also for both
Guy Morton--I have confirmed this also for both
Steve O'Neill
Roger Peckinbaugh--I have confirmed this also for both
Ray Schalk--I have confirmed this also for both
Walter Schang--I have confirmed this for Type 2
Milton Stock--I have confirmed this also for both
Pep Young --I have confirmed this also for both

-Cards on my list as "?" (you have listed as Type 2's):
Ping Bodie--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only
Jacques Fournier -I have confirmed this for Type 1 only
Hank Gowdy--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only
Tom Griffith--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only
Joe Judge--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only
Otto Miller--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only
W. Wambsganss - I don't have this card listed as having 2 variations w/ and w/o background– Type 1 of this card appears scanned in this thread; I only have confirmed Type 2 with the erroneous photo of Fritz Coumbe

-Cards not on my list at all (you have listed as Type 2's):
Jim Bagby--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only
Jake Daubert
Eppa Rixey, Jr.--I have confirmed this for Type 2 only


"And you're certain of the ones in red? I had a few of those listed as "?" on my list."

I may have to change my assessment of Evers, whose confirmation I can only find for Standard Biscuit, at least for the moment. The others I have confirmed; Eddie Collins (Huggins and Scott); Eddie Foster (Sterling); Rogers Hornsby w/e135 front (Legendary auctions);Walter Johnson (Goodwin); Tris Speaker (Bagger’s); and Ivy B. Wingo (Goodwin)
__________________
If we are to have another contest in the near future of our national existence, I predict that the dividing line will not be Mason and Dixon's but between patriotism and intelligence on the one side, and superstition, ambition and ignorance on the other. - Ulysses S. Grant, military commander, 18th US President.
Reply With Quote