[Aquarian Sports Cards]

If it was an unopened wax box and the gum had eaten through the bottom two cards in every pack but he had to open the packs to find that out ebay would still force you to accept the return. In essence nobody is "responsible" however anywhere besides ebay the buyer would be S.O.L. because he, in essence, altered the state of the poster by opening it. But, when you know ebay is going to find for the buyer regardless my theory is win the customer service points and volunteer the refund. Hopefully it's not a big hit.