I ran across a completed eBay sale of a 1985 Subway Geoff Zahn (Orange) that I unfortunately missed on, hopefully ArmourPhil won it. This confirms it exists.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/25592815925...p2047675.l2557
Updated Checklist
1. Buddy Bell (Yellow)
2. Mike Boddicker (Yellow)
3. Bill Buckner (Blue)
4. Rod Carew (Yellow)
5. Steve Carlton (Blue)
6. Cesar Cedeno (Red) (Green)
7. Cecil Cooper (Red) (Green)
8. Al Cowens (Blue) (Yellow)
9. Rich Gossage (Yellow)
10. Pedro Guerrero (Blue)
11. Ron Guidry (Blue)
12. Tony Gwynn (Green)
13. Mike Hargrove (Green)
14. Keith Hernandez (Orange)
15. Bob Horner (Yellow)
16. Kent Hrbek (Pink)
17. Rick Langford (Blue)
18. Jeff Leonard (Blue) (Yellow)
19. Willie McGee (Green)
20. Jack Morris (Red)
21. Jesse Orosco Yellow)
22. Terry Puhl (Orange)
23. Dan Quisenberry (Green) (Pink)
24. Johnny Ray (Orange)
25. Cal Ripken, Jr. (Blue) (Yellow)
26. Ryne Sandberg (Pink)
27. Mike Schmidt (Pink)
28. Tom Seaver (Green)
29. Rick Sutcliffe (Pink)
30. Bruce Sutter (Green) (Pink)
31. Alan Trammell (Orange)
32. Fernando Valenzuela (Blue) (Yellow)
33. Greg Walker (Red)
34. Willie Wilson (Green) (Red)
35. Dave Winfield (Pink)
36. Geoff Zahn (Orange)