Cal Ripken Jr.
Frank Robinson
Willie Mays
Jackie Robinson
Of course, they didn't have all the parameters that Jeff asked for going all the way back in time. For example, the ROY wasn't started until 1940, so guys like Cobb, Wagner, and Ruth could never have qualified for this question.
Derek Jeter was close, but he was only a WS MVP and All-Star MVP, but never a league MVP. I'm assuming Jeff meant the MVP designation as the overall league MVP. If not, and he's counting the WS and All-Star MVPs as well, then you can add Jeter to the list.
Forgot about Bench.
Last edited by BobC; 02-20-2023 at 08:16 PM.
|