Posted By:
Todd (nolemmings)Leave aside the fact that reprints exist and may be identical. Leave aside all the other garbage this seller slabs and auctions. Aren't at least some 54 SI cards legit?
The thread goes on again about this particular seller and how certain people need to be protected, others are too stupid to deserve protection, etc. I get it.
The SCD catalogue (at least from 1999) identifies the sheet, says singles are rarely encountered, but then lists values for individual "cards". Why wouldn't someone doing their homework conclude that these may be legit and accepted in the hobby? Again, what if these "cards" are indeed from 1954--suppose seller still has the subscription card or whatever other proof to show that they are not reprints. Then what exactly is the beef with regard to these and only these items?