[Archive]

Posted By: bcornell

First off, I'm glad to see the seller ("carleniv") come here to post - thanks.

Looking at the back of this card now, I still can't tell if SGC or PSA was right. If there's paper loss, it's very minimal. Grading is subjective and this card proves that favorite truism as well as any I've seen.

There's a tendency to attribute all questionable listings to malice on the part of the seller. I changed the title of this thread before the seller came on because I thought it was jumping to conclusions. Skepticism works well in most cases, but not in all of them, as this listing shows.

Bill