[Archive]

Posted By: JimB

As mentioned, it depends A LOT on the issue, but in general I would rank them as follows:

1. Cobb
1. Wagner
1. Jackson
4. Mathewson
4. Johnson
4. Young
7. Lajoie
7. Speaker
9. Plank
10. McGraw

Same # represents a virtual tie that can only be distinguished by the issue and relative rarity.


Edited to place the three greatest pitchers from the era at a virtual tie. I had Matty a step ahead on first thought.