Posted By:
andy beckerwe have all seen errors by both companies. i have had some from psa and some form sgc in my possesion from time to time. i do not scan these errors....save them for an sgc or psa bashing thread. i have the errors corrected and move on. so i guess i won't do too much walkin' on this thread either.
certainly both companies make errors. sgc will go a lot further to correct their mistakes. psa will correct their errors but i am not aware of them compensating anyone as a result of their mistake.
but i will tell you a couple stories from my experience....
i own an sgc graded s74-1, but when i spoke to sean and dave at last years national they both said they do not grade silks.
i also have had a rare issue variation returned by sgc for questionable authenticity. it is 100% authentic.
do they make mistakes or have inconsistancies, yes.
but they're human, as are all graders. not machines.
if you want to discuss certain cards, raw or graded....that's fine, imo. to bash a company (either) every single time the topic comes up is useless and after a while it does become annoying.