Posted By:
john/z28jd I dont think you can compare Jeter with other generations of players just based on the fact the midset at shortstop is much more different and id have to think he wouldve been moved to a different position back in the 70s when Smith started.Too big for SS,too much power potential and in the minors he was a horrible defender.You also have to remember Cal Ripken was a 3rd baseman to start,and because of his size,probably a better suited position for him,but he was an underrated defender.
Todd i just meant,coaches and managers see highlights and hear talk just like the rest of us.Theres poor choices for gold glove every year. Jeter doesnt even deserve consideration this year with Bentancourt,Cabrera,Uribe,Gonzalez and Michael Young all much better choices but id be willing to wager even money with anyone that Jeter will win it again.