Posted By:
Judge Dred (Fred)In the best of all worlds the dealer could have looked at the card and determined it was possibly trimmed. If it is obvious then perhaps the dealer could have included it in the item description. In this case it was graded by PSA. Similar situation in another recent thread except the card was graded a PSA7, the seller wrote NO PAPER LOSS in the item description and the buyer found there was paper loss. The scan provided by the seller wasn't real clear but the buyer trusted PSA to do a decent job of grading a PSA7 card.
Maybe the seller didn't notice this, maybe he did. In any case the seller indicated the following in the item description:
Seller's return policy: No Returns on Third Party Graded Material
I say start by asking PSA why they graded it. Tell them that you purchased the card because it was encapsulated by them with a numerical grade.
Yes - PSA probably blew it again... anyone want to jump on the bandwagon and turn this into a PSA sucks thread? They deserve it.
Why don't we have a PSA banner at the top of the page?