Posted By:
Steve fIt doesn't need to be all or nothing;
I'd recently purchased a E95. Upon receipt, the card had grown a new corner crease. The seller admitted it was damaged by him during packing. He apologized and asked if I wanted a complete refund. No way! It was difficult enough scoring this card, the chance of finding another, zippo.
We agreed on a grade decrease, and he agreed to refund one grade's worth SMR. Give it Hell Mark.