Posted By:
Jason LHey, they're both cheaters, but Jackson was better
besides, Pete had to wear shoes to be as good as he was!
Yes, Ozzie Smith is my favorite player, but even I would rank him 4th on that list...Honus, Banks, Ripken, Ozzie would be more appropriate - though I would like to think Ripken and Ozzie would be a tie...
Oh, and Eddie Mathews over Brooksie
Barry Bonds and McGwire really don't qualify since they weren't actually human
Really not sure Josh Gibson should be coming in 4th at Catcher, either...
nice question/thread - thanks!
edited to add: Gwynn really doesn't belong on that OF'ers list...that's kinda silly...and so is Molitor