[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

Jim- I want you to tell me how you would handle the following situation, and you have to put yourself in the consignor's position to answer it.

Suppose you consign a valuable PSA 8 to my auction. The winning bidder sends it to SGC, and they deem it trimmed. They then place it in an "altered" sleeve and I return it to you as such. So this expensive card that left your hands as an 8 comes back in a sleeve that renders it near worthless. How would you handle this (I know SGC could technically look at it without removing it from the holder, but that is very unscientific as they would not be able to examine the edges)?