[Archive]

Posted By: Al C.risafulli

Jim:

Again, I'm not trying to be disrespectful of anyone here, but I have a question.

Would you ask for a PSA9 with Charlie's seal of approval? Or mine? Or Leon's?

In other words, let's say I win the Global T205 Walter Johnson in Barry's auction (please, nobody bid on it, I'd like it). I receive the card in the mail after I've paid for it. Then I show it to, say, King, and King tells me he thinks it's been trimmed on the right edge. Global, by putting it in a holder, has rendered an opinion that the card is unaltered.

Should I then have the right to go back to Barry and get a refund on the card, because an independent second opinion (King) says it's been trimmed?

-Al

EDIT: Please note that I don't think the card - which is real - is trimmed. I should probably have used a hypothetical example instead of a real card in a real auction. Sorry about that.