[Archive]

Posted By: Chris East

Like has been previously voiced by a couple of posters in this thread, mine is a conditional vote: I vote "No- please put me out of my mysery and make it stop" But rather than the subject-matter, my vote is based on the manner in which the recent issue(s) has/have been presented.

I think 3rd party grading issues are extremely relevant with regard to vintage cards, and I have learned a lot about different companies/cards from many posts over the years. Observations like about the '33 Goudey Lajoie, or the REA/Mastro/PSA Nodgrass, etc, are extremely informative and timely.

But multiple threads on the same issue by the same poster is overbroad coverage. Had this been confined to a single thread...like the jaffe-Morales thread, I would feel differently. But at the time of my post 5 of the 15 most recent posts were started by a single username on the same subject.