Posted By:
CoreyRS.hanus"....but theoretically, if you were willing to pay $X for a card, how the bidding got to your high number really shouldn't matter."
Just because I'm willing to pay $X for it, doesn't mean I wouldn't want to get it for less than that if I could. So to the extent the shilling made me pay a price higher than I would have had to than without the shilling, it sure would matter to me.