Posted By:
Matt"But, again, since I as a buyer have never paid more for a card than it was worth to me at the time, my happiness as a buyer means I am not all that concerned about whether the seller exercised the utmost moralilty in the sale."
That's the point that many of us disagree with you on. Personally I disagree for 2 reasons:
1) If he is dishonest, I don't want anything to do with the transaction out of fear he may be cheating me some other way (the argument above that you can't be only a little dishonest).
2) It's not good for the future of the hobby to support dishonest sellers.