Posted By:
LetsGoBucsWhat is even worse is that Reynolds almost made it.
Gordon was a good solid ballplayer. He was on some winning teams. He's a minor star. He doesn't belong in the HOF IMO.
At this rate we'll need to reconsider guys like Bill Madlock, Dick Groat, Al Oliver, etc.
Perhaps what needs to be done is to have a HOF which is really a HOF. And then have a Hall of Stars next to it where they can induct people due to being a star for a period of time, or a really great character, or having done something out of the ordinary or very well in the playoffs or for a few years, etc.
I just can't get excited about finding all my joe gordon cards because he's a HOF now.