Posted By:
James GalloFred- I knew by the pictures that card was not torn or repaired so I expected a SGC 10, therefore my expectations were not met because the card was altered.
I expected better customer service and the refund was only offered after 20 minutes of arguing.
I bought a group of cards in a Huggins and Scott auction, one of the major cards in the lot came back trimmed by SGC. BIll talked to me right away and offered me a nice credit to his future auctions. There was no discussion it was not a problem and I didn't get the run around.
It should be this simple, I shouldn't have to go back and forth.
That being said even if it seems that most of you don't agree, I do think there is a big difference between buying a low grade card that is trimmed and one that isn't and I am surprised that many of you don't seem to agree with me.
I wonder if this was a high dollar card if the opinions would differ.
If I was in the seller's place I think I would have given the $75 refund without a discussion and argument and that would have been that.
James G
Looking for 1915 Cracker Jacks and 1909-11 American Caramel E90-1.