[cardsagain74]

Even though it naturally has a lot of great qualities, I would've guessed that the combo bottom right corner and t/b centering would have taken it down to a 6 max to start with. And then that wrinkling would've meant a best case 3.5, and most likely 2.5/3

I'd return it.

Edit: Can see the posters above feel differently. I don't doubt there could be some exceptions out there, but I cannot remember ever seeing a "noticeably creased" PSA 4 (unless you're referring to slight small corner folds), much less multiple ones. And have always felt something getting a 4 is usually the typical corner/edge/centering issues that go with the territory of a midgrade card, so I would have expected the downgrade to be from minor edge issues somewhere that you couldn't easily see or something like that. I totally disagree with so much slack being given to that Berra getting that high of a grade.