Quote:
Originally Posted by MooseWithFleas
1.) Pujols
2.) Gehrig
3.) Foxx
4.) Bagwell
5.) Thomas
Gehrig is rated pretty fairly, but Foxx is not talked about enough. Both are great players, but Gehrig gets the edge.
|
If you are talking offensive stats only and discounting the fact he was DH for a few years, Frank Thomas is better than Bagwell. I don't even think there is an argument there. But obviously if you include defense then a good argument can be made.