[Archive]

Posted By: identify7

I'd put Robinson and Mantle on the bench.
Robinson because he really was not very productive after 1954.
And Mantle because his popularity has little to do with his on field performance.
I'd much rather see Musial in the OF, and Hodges on 1B. Hodges out HRed and out RBIed Mantle by a mile in the 50s.
And on 2nd, I'd go for Schoendienst.