Figured I'd start a thread lamenting PSA's grading practices, as this seemed like a novel idea.
But hopefully with a twist.
Just got back a batch of cards from PSA, and while most were better than expected, of course there would be a few head scratchers. This graded a 1, even though one in worse overall condition (with similar border chipping) got a 2, and one got a 5 MC with obvious chipping since it totally broke the black outline in a few places.
Larger images available as:
https://imageshack.com/a/img921/3681/69JjBw.jpg
https://imageshack.com/a/img922/4531/PcPfK3.jpg
In any case, for bragging rights alone, show us you most head scratching PSA 1s (or SGC 10s).