[Archive]

Posted By: Red

If Paypal didn't require a letter from a dealer or authenticator then any buyer could return anything they wanted to for any reason using the authenticity excuse. If a seller says no returns in his auction you are entitled to a refund if he sends you a fake card. If he calls a real card VG and you think it's only GD-VG+ you can't return it, and you can't just make up that it's fake in order to be allowed to return it. Paypal wants a letter from somebody in the business stating it's fake. The person issuing the document is responsible for the accuracy of their opinion. If it turns out the item isn't fake, and the person issuing the opinion is incorrect, then that person is legally responsible for what they stated in the letter.