[Archive]

Posted By: Julie

though most of us (including Bill James) would agree about having a smaller HOF with only the "first tier" HOFers--there's a great divergence of opinion about who the "first tier" consists of!

Whether you believe that Jackson belongs in or not, I think a lot of people wince a little when James says of those who do believe he should be in: "Wanting Jackson in the HOF is being like the housewives who go to the courthouse because they're dying to see the cute murderer."