Quote:
Originally Posted by glynparson
I am sorry but I strongly disagree with you. those cards absolutely look properly graded to me and I do not feel they would have graded higher with psa in fact I feel two have a shot at being lower not higher from psa. Just one man’s opinion but i have had thousands and thousands of cards graded by them.
|
Except for the old Mathews and old Berra. Those cards are clearly over graded. I have been working on up grading my t205 set to PSA/SGC 5 or better, but often when I find a card and compare it to my 4 or 4.5, the 4 or 4.5 is nicer so I pass. I don't know if the grading standards are tighter or maybe the companies are just doing a better training graders and there are fewer errors. It makes sense to me that dealers and collectors who have over graded cards would want to move them sooner rather than later. If the card is properly graded in an old holder, they wouldn't have a problem keeping it. So, you would see a lot of over graded cards in old holders for sale.