[Archive]

Posted By: Anthony

Paul- take the cert numbers on my 2 cards. Plug those numbers into the cert lookup on psa's data base, and add or subtract to the cert number to get the 10 cards on either side. LOTS of Leafs in those 2 submissions rejected for evid of trim. Dan M. had a post last week on CU about a similar occurance and the discussion was whether a grading company should reject an entire submission if a large % turns out to be trimmed. I think they should once it hits about 30%. Based on my 2 cards that don't look good to me I think they were trimmed but the graders missed them- and if 90% of a submission has trimmed cards I would be inclined to think the rest were as well.
I"m not blaming the seller- he does a lot of consignments, and besides, the whole point of 3rd party grading is that they certify the card as legit. We all want lower grading fees, but you can't have it both ways. Like they say: good, fast or cheap- pick 2.

edited to add my name.