Here is a short post from last year from a thread call "Grading Companys" from the non-sports side on similar N224 cards sold the same week and the results. Not statistically definitive though.
..........Just waited to see how the SGC Kinney Military cards graded 80 (which they also call a 6) compared to the PSA Kinney Military cards graded 6.
Same grade, different companies. PSA got $14 on average while SGC got $18 on average..........
But what is interesting is a post on the thread from a PSA customer where he said he has submitted between 50-100 SGC cards (broken out) and NEVER has received a higher grade from PSA. I believe him. That was a year or more ago. That is not the case anymore (see a few posts above). It is apparent that PSA has loosened grading standards and that is what I am basing my opinions on, along with their financial results. Again, see the Arthur Anderson comparison.
Now looking for the other comparison threads.
And Jamie, no lies or falsehoods in anything I've written.
Eric
Last edited by egbeachley; 06-18-2009 at 10:32 PM.
|