[Archive]

Posted By: warshawlaw

These are actual prices compiled over the last year. Nice examples in legit slabs would sell for several hundred dollars, at least, as you can see from the list below, and Sullivan is worth a heck of a lot more than $2,500 in decent shape. The stars in the set include several HOF boxers and famous boxers such as Jack Dempsey, Jake Kilrain, Billy Edwards, Paddy Ryan, George LaBlanche, Yankee Sullivan, etc.

Ashton p $329.95
Cardiff p $140.40
Chambers p (corner missing o/w ok) $224.50
Coburn p (major front damage) $34.00; f $190.49
Dempsey p $535.00
Flood SGC 30 $460.00
Greenfield p-f $106.49
McAuliffe p $787.00
McCoy g-vg $152.50
Pendergast vg $717.00
Sullivan (front) vg $4,494.00
Woodson g-vg $687.00
Lot (7) Flood PSA 4, Cleary SGC 50, Edwards SGC 20, Mace SGC 10, Chambers SGC 40, McCoy SGC 20, La Blanche SGC 30. $6,380.00


Full disclosure here: While I'd normally not provide pricing data publicly except with my book, I am showing actual prices realized rather than providing an estimate because I am bidding on various lots in a current auction of these cards and I do not want anyone to feel that I have been misstating the facts here to avoid competition in the auction.