[Archive]

Posted By: Paul

Quite a number of really poor Hall of Famers haven't been mentioned: Tommy McCarthy, Harry Hooper, Rick Ferrell, Roger Bresnahan, Travis Jackson, George Kelly, Bid McPhee. These guys all have to go.

I would not consider Robin Roberts borderline. He clearly belongs.

It shouldn't come as a surpise that many people would consider Jim Rice borderline. He just barely made it in his 15th year. By definition, he is borderline. That doesn't mean that he does not belong. He's just right at the edge, at least in the opinions of the voters.