Posted By:
PeterI sent in 25 cards to PSA for crossover recently and was very disapointed with the results.
6 GAI cards - 2 crossed over and 4 rejected
(I was willing to take min. grades of .5-1 less)
13 SGC cards - 7 crossed over and 6 rejected (largest value cards all rejected)
(I wanted equal grades for them)
4 Beckett cards - 3 crossed over and 1 rejected as trimmed (large value card rejected as being trimmed and I do not believe it is - grader error)
(I wanted equal grades for them)
2 other - both rejected
(the 1 I would take any PSA grade was rejected as trimmed.
The most disapointing aspect to me in this process was the fact that they would not cross over 6 of my SGC cards to an equal grade. Is PSA superior to SGC in determining a cards true grade? All of the higher value cards in this submission were rejected for crossover ($800 - $1850 USD value cards).