[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

Those are two really nice Old Judge. For common non-HOFers a nice unslabbed card should go for about $300. Slabbed cards go alot higher as we saw the other night when BMW sold an SGC86 for $1000.HOFer prices vary widely based on scarcity. A Ward in average condition should sell for about $600-$700, while a McPhee (or Wright, or Delahanty, or Connor, or Mack) in the same condition could sell for many times that amount. The most valuable cards are not HOFers, but rare non-HOFers. These can sell for tens of thousands of dollars and in one or two cases, if the stars are properly alligned, could hit six figures.