I have a newer lighthouse label PSA 10 Jeter Murphy that looks a lot better than the second generation holdered one I used to own. Foil looked dull and chipped in spots on the older one. I personally search for more recent graded cards if possible and have sold/replaced old holders with newer slabbed cards where possible.
I have read people thinking newer slabbed cards (hologram on front) and the lighthouse label ones are when PSA was grading more strongly vs in the earlier 2000's. But its probably just a matter of opinion vs real comparisons.
|