Mark,
Thanks for posting that. That example is exactly the point a few of us have made.
Travis,
It's not that I think that it couldn't be a duplicate image that was certed incorrectly, as we all know PSA/JSA have made blunders similarly before. IMHO, I don't think there is enough evidence here to say for sure that that is what has happened.
I tend to agree with Jim, Dave, and Steve that people have no idea of accurate grading. It's also very possible some repair was done in between the last purchase and when this seller obtained the item. Perhaps, they have no idea anything had been done to it, and are only reporting what they see.
Best,
Mark
|