Posted By:
leonWE have hashed this debate out many times. There is no right or wrong answer. It is truly what you believe is a rookie card is a rookie card. What you believe qualifies as a card is a card. I think my '25 Gerhig Exhibit is a card. To be devils advocate (because I basically believe a rookie card has to be a ML'er) let's think about this. The term "rookie" and "card". I could argue that rookie means "1st" and "card" means well.... card. With that being said then technically Ruth's rookie "card" or 1st card ...is his Baltimore News one.... Since Andy is a good friend I will go with Ruth's rookie as his M101-5 card....but I too would prefer something other than a blank backed one.....just my 1/2 cent worth....regards all