Posted By:
H MurphyHard to judge pitchers without seeing them in person but here goes my take.
1-Walter Johnson, the #`s the rep and the longevity speak for themselves
2-C Mathewson, much the same as above not quite as dominant
3-Warren Spahn, the "Stan Musial" of pitching
4-S Paige, the biggest "if only" pitcher in history
5-Steve Carlton, the best pitching career I`ve seen from start to finish
ADDED BONUS, my Favorite "have to win today`s game pitcher" El Tiante, Louie Tiant!